Blog | 29 May 2024

Government bonds will not return as diversifiers soon

Alessandro Theiss

Director, Financial Modelling and Scenario

With the May update of our Global Economic Model, we added government bond total return indices for a selection of countries and regional aggregates. This model enhancement allows users to easily gauge our baseline forecast for government bond returns, and how these vary in alternative scenarios. Our modelling framework also allows users to understand which factors are most important in driving these return projections.

A decomposition into capital gains, yield income (coupon payments), and roll-down return shows that for many advanced economies (AEs) our upbeat return expectations are predicated on yields falling back from their current elevated levels. For emerging markets, structurally high interest rates provide a healthy cushion for returns, while the relative contribution from capital gains to total returns is generally more limited. But the rollercoaster of US rate expectations and a strong US dollar will continue to skew the risk-reward profile for investing in EMs.

Beyond considerations around the magnitude and volatility of expected returns from an asset class, investors need to worry about the correlation between returns from the various asset classes held in their portfolios. This enables them to shield their portfolios from excessive losses during episodes of market distress. The correlation between equity and government bond returns is particularly important in this context, as these two asset classes generally account for the largest shares in traditional portfolios.

The striking commonality of the stock-bond correlation (SBC) across AEs can be explained by many of the factors affecting the SBC being determined as much by global development as by domestic ones. For example, the period following the Global Financial Crisis, during which the SBC was strongly negative, was characterised by low and stable inflation and interest rates, fiscal consolidation to repair public balance sheets, and an absence of large global supply shocks. These driving forces have all been upended in the aftermaths of the Covid-19 pandemic. In response, the SBC became strongly positive, reducing the hedging properties of government bonds and the risk-reward profile of a standard investment portfolio. 

It seems likely that the SBC will remain positive and elevated for several reasons. Central banks’ fight against inflation is not fully over and more shifts in central bank reaction functions can be expected. As a result, uncertainty about the future path for interest rates will remain elevated which is supportive of a positive SBC. Furthermore, we expect that geopolitical instability and a more extreme climate will cause more supply shocks in the future, increasing inflation volatility and keeping risk premia elevated.

Indeed, when assessing the implied predictions for the SBC from our Global Economic Model across a range of alternative scenarios, we generally find little scope for a reversal to a negative correlation in the near term. This does not only hold true in our downside scenarios but also in our upside scenario, where inflation is brought under control faster than what we expect in our base case forecast. While a traditional investment portfolio would see higher returns than in the base case in this scenario, bonds would still not act as diversifiers.

You may be interested in

Africa: A continent besieged along old fault lines

Africa has, once again, taken centre stage as countries vie for the top spot. The playing field has shifted slightly, and the rules of engagement have moved more toward the economic arena. In this Research Briefing, we explore the economic and political ties between Africa and China, the US, Europe and Russia as the continent navigates the new multi-polar world order.

Find Out More

A year older, none the wiser ‒ a fractious GNU stumbles on

South Africa's Government of National Unity (GNU) has struggled over the one year of its existence, largely because of the ad hoc manner in which it was assembled.

Find Out More

The Green Leap – Project bankability takes centre stage

The report argues that enhancing project bankability should become a main policy priority as part of climate investment endeavors.

Find Out More

What does the critical minerals boom mean for Africa? | Greenomics podcast

As demand grows for critical minerals like cobalt, copper, and lithium, African nations are navigating opportunities and risks—from boosting local employment to managing geopolitical tensions and environmental concerns.

Find Out More